Showing posts with label Legitimation crisis at the GOP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Legitimation crisis at the GOP. Show all posts

Thursday, March 5, 2009

The GOP's Rush Limbaugh problem

“If you’re a talk radio host and you have five million who listen and there are 50 million who hate you, you make a nice living. If you’re a Republican party, you’re marginalized.” David Frum, quoted here.

At the moment the GOP is beset by an internal contradiction. On one hand are the interests of the organization as a whole. On the other hand are the interests of the separate parts. The problem is, these interests go in differing directions.

At present, the party's interests rest on adapting to meet new conditions: the bubble has burst regarding recent political and economic beliefs about things like war, tax cuts, and economic policy. The Republican Party needs to adapt to changed times.

But the Republican congress and media members -- the parts -- want to ride out the same facade and keep their jobs just a little bit longer. I mean, Rush Limbaugh can't tomorrow on his radio show say, you know all those things I said about Democrats over the years? They aren't really that bad. He can't do this, because his show would lose its reason for existence. The Republican Congress strikes me as in much the same predicament. In other words, they are what they are -- and for the time being, these men and women are employed, even slightly relevant. I can't help but find their self-preserving actions reasonable, in this sense.

But these ego-centered actions on the part of the individuals come at a time when the growth and stability of the party, as a whole, face specific external challenges. It is clear to anyone with eyes we need new approaches to domestic and international policies. In large part, organizational power will come from meeting head-on these new realities, not by grasping to disproven ideologies and picked-over code words (i.e., propaganda).

If the goal of the organization is to out-live any of its current parts, even Mr. Limbaugh, then the men and women who have been given riches and power and cultural satisfaction from this party ought to think about how to go about giving a little bit back. Straightening the whole operation out, smoothing things over, leaving something behind rather than taking and taking till there's nothing left.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

More from President Obama

I am hearing criticism of the President that his speech last night was short on 'details.' That's fine. It was. But I think the criticism misses the point. America can't actually claim to know its details right now. Until we see the consequences of Iraq, and find the actual market value of our troubled assets, the details of our economy and our political strength are in question. What Obama really has to say is about ideas: old ideas are dead and tried; new ideas are necessary and responsible.

For example, watching last night and now reading the transcript of his speech, I was struck by the extent he lectured America's political elites for their behavior the past few decades. Especially here:

Now, if we're honest with ourselves, we'll admit that for too long we have not always met these responsibilities, as a government or as a people. I say this not to lay blame or to look backwards, but because it is only by understanding how we arrived at this moment that we'll be able to lift ourselves out of this predicament.

The fact is, our economy did not fall into decline overnight. Nor did all of our problems begin when the housing market collapsed or the stock market sank.

We have known for decades that our survival depends on finding new sources of energy, yet we import more oil today than ever before.

The cost of health care eats up more and more of our savings each year, yet we keep delaying reform.

Our children will compete for jobs in a global economy that too many of our schools do not prepare them for.

And though all of these challenges went unsolved, we still managed to spend more money and pile up more debt, both as individuals and through our government, than ever before.

In other words, we have lived through an era where too often short-term gains were prized over long-term prosperity, where we failed to look beyond the next payment, the next quarter, or the next election.

A surplus became an excuse to transfer wealth to the wealthy instead of an opportunity to invest in our future. Regulations...

(APPLAUSE)

Regulations -- regulations were gutted for the sake of a quick profit at the expense of a healthy market. People bought homes they knew they couldn't afford from banks and lenders who pushed those bad loans anyway. And all the while, critical debates and difficult decisions were put off for some other time on some other day.

Well, that day of reckoning has arrived, and the time to take charge of our future is here.

Now is the time to act boldly and wisely, to not only revive this economy, but to build a new foundation for lasting prosperity.

--If I hear him right, his 'better' ideas are comprehensive reform of the way we burn energy, the way we take care of our health, and the way we educate.

--The GOP is in some trouble. It is steadily becoming accepted knowledge that, as Obama points out, these are, at the very least, the best ideas coming out of Washington in quite some time. And these ideas directly contradict the anti-planning ethos of the Republican Party.

--I look forward to his budget, which I believe is released on Thursday.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Obama and the GOP

Yesterday I linked to a defense of President Obama's commitment to bipartisanship. The problem with the idea of bipartisanship is this: the best bill is the best bill, regardless of who supports it. Let's be technical and thoughtful about this, not political.

As a philosophy, that argument is probably right. However, it is in reality untenable. The stimulus bill, in fact the whole economic crisis, has both political causes and political consequences. Politics have already played a part in it, and will continue to do so. The very way we go about imagining the 'best bill' is shaped by political motivations.

Beyond that, this whole question of bipartisanship is particularly interesting because of the way Obama is approaching it. It seems, due to his own motivations and his own reasons, President Obama wants to pressure the Republican congress into major changes with its mode of operation, or face obliteration. He is not nearly as accommodating to GOP norms as the Clintons were, and seem to still be. Am I missing something when I think this?

Obama is basically saying, GOP, lose your tired ideologies, join the mainstream, and get to work -- or continue your trend toward irrelevance. Be more like the rest of us, or, while you sit out governance, we will continue to pass massive spending bills.

However, the current Republicans know they can't go back to their constituents and say, you know all those things we've told you the past fifteen years? That Democrats hang with terrorists? That they are baby-killers and want to raise all your taxes? Yeah, really, these Democrats are all right. It is reasonable of them to conclude they can't say that, not after the demonization of recent times.

So instead of joining Obama, they continue to go along with their old charade, because they assume, at the very least, they'll continue to get re-elected to office by their conservative districts or states. They just won't have any legitimacy to do anything once in Washington.

My point is, the GOP seriously needs a new plan.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Bipartisanship

The New Yorker's Hendrik Hertzberg defends President Obama's commitment to 'bipartisanship':

Fifty years ago, the civil-rights movement understood that nonviolence can be an effective weapon even if—or especially if—the other side refuses to follow suit. Obama has a similarly tough-minded understanding of the political uses of bipartisanship, which, even if it fails as a tactic for compromise, can succeed as a tonal strategy: once the other side makes itself appear intransigently, destructively partisan, the game is half won. Obama is learning to throw the ball harder. But it’s not Rovian hardball he’s playing. More like Gandhian hardball.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Bill Clinton calls the GOP's actions 'automatic'

“Those guys are on automatic,” Clinton said during an interview on CNN’s “American Morning.” “They have a — you know, you punch a button and they give you the answer they give you.”

His use of the description 'automatic' is interesting because it strikes me as a spot-on description of what the Republicans propose -- a market system in which tax cuts are the answer to everything. Except for their three Northeast senators, the entire GOP congress voted against the stimulus plan as 'big government.' In rejecting the plan, they used the same logic they've used since the early 1990s. The GOP wants to preclude economic planning of any sort, and put all their eggs in cutting taxes. When something happens, regardless of the conditions, the answer is the same -- lower taxes.

Anything different than that viewpoint is 'socialism.'

Now, I like tax cuts and believe they have a place in good economic policy. But a hypothesis of mine is that Americans are starting, slowly, to see that a theory with such dedication to its truth without regard to reality can't help but often be wrong.

In this sense, as knowledge, President Obama's stimulus plan represents the mind to use public logic and government institutions to counter socially destructive consequences of economic activity, especially those events that threaten the capacity for free economic activity in the first place. That it is good for markets to employ this more thoughtful understanding of how they work.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

Economic theory and the GOP

From the point of view of their own interests, it strikes me that the GOP could use a new theory of economics. The free-market model they are used to has lost immense amounts of credibility, and the future doesn't look any better for the increasingly worn doctrine. Does the GOP want to be the party of a few faithful surrounded by many adapting to new conditions? What happens when the few faithful pass along? What will be the GOP's public base? Can it stand on religion and war alone? What happens when the meaning of religion and war change? Will they get passed by while standing for 'principle' there too?

However, I agree the circumstances are tricky. The GOP should not want to jeopardize its closeness to America's power elite, which to me is the only reason the GOP would want to maintain the silly free-market message that the elite appreciate so much. But power relations are not everything. The GOP needs national public support, too. Because of this need, I tend to think the GOP should search for a new economic message, one that can resonate with increasingly reasoning Americans.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Gold: A political reflection

I notice this morning that gold is back over $900. As you can see from the above data-image, this is just about a historical high-point (the above data-image only goes through about 2006). However, it is interesting, a bit of a curiosity in fact, that gold is actually lower today than it was a year ago, that is, lower than it was prior to last March, before the Bear Stearns collapse, and before the major interest rate slashing and monetary easing of the Fed. Due to the loose monetary policies of the past twelve months, we might, theoretically speaking, have expected the price of gold to have risen the past year, perhaps dramatically. Instead, it's stayed even, and actually dropped a slight bit. But still: that chart above is fascinating, in light of the fact that all the investors who since 1971 have poured their money into gold and driven up the price are, in effect, betting against the dollar.

One other thing about the data. Notice how the price of gold hits a high in the seventies before dropping from 1980 until 2000. Then look at the rise of gold this decade, under the economic stewardship of the Bush Administration. Remember: the high price of gold reflects, among other things, a percevied instability of the dollar. So the high price of gold is, as i see it, another reason to laugh at modern-day Republicans who consider themselves 'conservative.' Besides the attempt to radically re-make America into a fundamentalist paradise, and the unleashing of war to re-make the planet into a tyrant-less world, Republican monetary and fiscal policies have been similarly radical. The price of gold reflects the de-stabilization of the US economy during the recent Republican rule. There is little doubt gold is up and the dollar weaker because of the wild foriegn and domestic policies of the previous administration.

I am sure I am missing something, and perhaps I am over-reacting to the mangled and moronic radicalism of the Bush Administration, but my thesis that President Obama is the first real conservative president since Eisenhower just seems accurate to me. The ironic thing is that he is a conservative who markets himself a progressive (using the single-word mantra, 'change'), while everyone else since Eisenhower strikes me as change-oriented, power-grabbers who call themselves conservatives, or in Clinton's case, a 'New Democrat' (i.e., a conservative Democrat).

I do hope the Republican Party dedicates itself to a more sophisticated reading of political philosophy, and thus a more learned understanding of what it means to be a conservative. The country really could use a force for stability. The utopia vision of the Bush years should be put squarely into history. Maybe then we'd see gold prices go down, and confidence in the dollar -- and in the US economy -- go back up.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Iraq: A war lost and a presidency failed

The famed and amazingly well-connected Washington journalist Bob Woodward has an interesting article here. In it, he lists ten lessons for President Obama to learn from what he calls the "troubled presidency of George W. Bush." Here's the first thing:

1. Presidents set the tone. Don't be passive or tolerate virulent divisions.

In the fall of 2002, Bush witnessed a startling face-off between National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice and Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld in the White House Situation Room after Rumsfeld had briefed the National Security Council on the Iraq war plan. Rice wanted to hold on to a copy of the Pentagon briefing slides, code-named Polo Step. "You won't be needing that," Rumsfeld said, reaching across the table and snatching the Top Secret packet away from Rice -- in front of the president. "I'll let you two work it out," Bush said, then turned and walked out. Rice had to send an aide to the Pentagon to get a bootlegged copy from the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Bush should never have put up with Rumsfeld's power play. Instead of a team of rivals, Bush wound up with a team of back-stabbers with long-running, poisonous disagreements about foreign policy fundamentals.

Speaking of Iraq, if you listen to official-Washington speak you hear things like 'the Surge worked,' or 'we are winning.' I've even heard 'we've won.'

I thought of such official-speak upon reading this article in the London Review of Books, written by Patrick Cockburn. It is titled 'America Concedes.' From reading it I learned that,

On 27 November the Iraqi parliament voted by a large majority in favour of a security agreement with the US under which its 150,000 troops will withdraw from Iraqi cities, towns and villages by 30 June next year and from all of Iraq by 31 December 2011. The Iraqi government will take over military responsibility for the Green Zone in Baghdad, the heart of American power in Iraq, in a few weeks’ time. Private security companies will lose legal immunity. US military operations will only be carried out with Iraqi consent. No US military bases will remain after the last American troops leave in 2011 and in the interim the US military is banned from carrying out attacks on other countries from within Iraq.

The Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA), signed after eight months of rancorous negotiations, is categorical and unconditional. America’s bid to act as the world’s only super-power and to establish quasi-colonial control of Iraq, an attempt that began with the invasion of 2003, has ended in failure. There will be a national referendum on the new agreement next July, but the accord is to be implemented immediately, so the poll will be largely irrelevant. Even Iran, which had denounced the first drafts of the SOFA, fearing that any agreement would enshrine a permanent US presence in Iraq, now says that it will officially back the new security pact after the referendum: a sure sign that America’s main rival in the Middle East sees the accord as marking the end of the occupation and the end of any notion of Iraq being used as a launching-pad for military assaults on its neighbours.

Astonishingly, this momentous agreement was greeted with little surprise or interest outside Iraq. On the day that it was finally passed by the Iraqi parliament international attention was focused on the terrorist attacks in Mumbai. For some months polls in the US have shown that the economic crisis has replaced the Iraqi war in the minds of American voters. In any case, Bush has declared so many spurious milestones to have been passed in Iraq over the years that when a real turning point is reached people are naturally sceptical about its significance. The White House is anyway so keen to keep quiet about what it has agreed in Iraq that it hasn’t even published a copy of the SOFA in English. Some senior officials in the Pentagon privately criticise Bush for conceding so much, but the American media are fixated on the incoming Obama administration and no longer pay much attention to the doings of Bush and Co.

. . . .

The Iraqi government will become stronger as the Americans begin to depart. It will also be forced to take full responsibility for the failings of the Iraqi state. This comes at a bad moment for the government because the price of oil, the state’s only source of revenue, has fallen to $50 a barrel, when the budget assumed it would be $80. Many state salaries – those of teachers, for example – were doubled on the strength of this estimate. Communal differences are still largely unresolved. Although friction between Sunni and Shia, bad though it is, is less than it was two years ago, hostility between Arabs and Kurds is deepening. The departure of the US military frightens many Sunni, who will be at the mercy of the majority Shia. But it is also an incentive for the three main communities to come to an agreement about their relations with one another: there will soon be no Americans left to stand between them. America’s troops will depart, leaving behind a ruined country.

The thesis of the article seems to be this: Any bogus official-speak notwithstanding, America has in reality lost the Iraq War.

Monday, December 15, 2008

Hendrik Hertzberg pokes a tiny whole in the GOP charade on abortion

What a deft piece of political writing the following is.

It is from Hendrik Hertzberg's blog. Mr. Hertzberg is a writer at The New Yorker and former speechwriter for President Carter. He starts by quoting "Kathryn Jean (K-Lo) Lopez, head honcha of National Review Onlinem explaining why Governor Palin is her leader:"

"What is it about Sarah?

For many folks on the Right, she represented an influx of social conservatism in the campaign. All she had to do was arrive at the scene with her son Trig to demonstrate her pro-life bona fides. Some estimated 90 percent of Americans faced with the knowledge that they might give birth to a child with Down Syndrome wouldn’t have made the choice she and her husband, Todd, did to let the child live."

I detect some assumptions here. (1) Palin’s carrying Trig to term was a choice. (2) The choice was hers and her husband’s to make, not God’s or the government’s. (3) She deserves praise for having chosen the choice she chose.

But if Palin (and Lopez) were truly “pro-life”—if they truly believed that abortion, especially elective abortion in the first trimester, is murder or at least unjustifiable homicide—then having Trig was not a choice. It was a simple matter of obedience to God’s law, which is infinitely more sacrosanct than man’s law. Palin no more deserves praise for it than I deserve praise for not having lately gunned down any friends, colleagues, or strangers.

What this demonstrates is that even in the minds of anti-abortion zealots, abortion is now implicitly viewed in the same light as divorce: an unfortunate choice, a reprehensible choice, a choice that may even contravene the will of God, but still a choice. And, again implicitly, the choice that Sarah Palin had every right to make. In both directions.

This is why, even if Roe v. Wade is eventually overturned, it will always be legal to get an abortion somewhere in the United States of America.

Source.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Sarah Palin should subtly disavow Joe the Plumber

Apparently Joe the Plumber was on a radio show the other day trashing John McCain and praising Sarah Palin. I have no stake, but Sarah Palin needs to distance herself from the nonsense that is Joe the Plumber. I don't know Joe as a man, but the Joe-the-Plumber character he plays in the media is a dope. He symbolically represents stupidity and ignorance. Some politicians, like President Obama and Sen. McCain, have the legitimacy as people seen as smart to make overtures, if ever so subtly, with what Joe the Plumber represents. For President Obama and Sen. McCain, reaching out to him is an attempt to expand their range of supporters while spending replenishable political capital.

At the present moment, Sarah Palin has none of that smart-person legitimacy and does not have such political capital to spend. That could change, but right now, the Joe the Plumber crowd is Gov. Palin's base. Gov. Palin thus has a different task concerning JP's stupidity: she needs to dissociate herself from him a bit. His symbolic meaning is such a turn-off to all but a narrow range of Americans, that to expand her range of supporters means she cannot be seen as associated with him. To have any chance at the presidency in 2012 or 2016, Gov. Palin needs to separate herself from the character named Joe the Plumber. She needs to do so subtly, but unquestionably.

To win in the future, you must run to the center, Governor.

I'm in the minority here, but I think there are clear ways that you can do that.

Saturday, November 8, 2008

McCain the Faux Maverick

McCain . . . has the amateur chess player's weakness for making an impulsive move just to see what will happen: thus his eleventh-hour intervention in the Wall Street crisis negotiations. In chess what almost always happens after the impulsive move is doom.

Russel Baker, Oct 7 2008, NY Review of Books

The last thing I want to do is pile on a man who just lost the job he wanted more than any other. Sen. McCain's life-ambition, so it seems, was to be commander-in-chief of the US military. And just because he's a politician, and ran a typical politican's campaign, doesn't mean he's not mending a broken heart right now.

But I want to say something about Sen. McCain's so-called 'maverick' persona. A maverick, by definition, is an individual that strays from the pack. An individual who takes his or her own path to wherever it is he or she wants to go. An individual who decides for himself where it is he wants to go in the first place.

The world is a tricky place, however. Getting anywhere requires reading the tea leaves. As such, it is almost impossible for an individual to succeed when he has only his own wisdom upon which to rely. An individual who relies on himself for inspiration must be able to read his environment all by himself, or be condemned, as the quote above puts it, to the lonely path of "doom." It is the trickiness of the real-world, not weak-minded pansiness, that explains why most people eschew being a maverick and turn to company. Life ain't an easy road when you travel it alone.

So what does Sen. McCain's record tell us about the quality of his 'maverickness'? Well, let's see. Sen. McCain has run for president twice. It strikes me that, both times, he has spectacularly failed at reading his environment for what it was. In 2000, he ran an 'Obama campaign' in a Bush Environment. In 2008 he ran a 'Bush campaign' in an Obama Environment. What I mean is, in 2000 rabid partisanship ruled. McCain ran a centrist, can't-we-all-get-along campaign. In 2008, there was a strong anti-partisanship-backlash, put in motion by Barack Obama in his 2004 speech, when he said:

We don't have blue states, we don't have red states, we are the United States

But 2008 saw Sen. McCain run a campaign in which he ignored what was on people's minds -- how to fix problems in a spirit of bi-partisanship. Rather, Sen. McCain focused his campaign on his opponent's questionable patriotism and the made-up charge that his opponent was a socialist. To top it off, he took Sarah Palin --an unknown, attractive, fresh voice -- and turned her into his attack-dog VP. What a waste.

The point is this. The last thing America needs following President Bush is a go-it-my-own-way president whose own way is ignorant of real-world facts and knowledge.

In contrast, millions upon millions of Americans made the right choice in choosing Sen. Obama. Sometimes with the pack is the wise way to go.

Friday, November 7, 2008

Karl Rove on why the Republicans lost

So how did Barack Obama win? . . . Some of it was circumstance: The October Surprise arrived a month early and framed the election in the best possible way for Mr. Obama (and the worst possible way for John McCain).

This is Karl Rove writing on the WSJ website.

Mr. Rove's explanation has to do with his party's recent loss, but his words actually say a lot more about the problem with the GOP going forward. In a nutshell, Mr. Rove explains the 2008 debacle in this way: The Republicans have no answer to America's real-world problems. When the economic crisis became widely apparent, the GOP had nothing in their intellectual basket to deal with it.

If Mr. Rove and the GOP hope that in 2012 and 2016 such 'circumstance' goes away and the race will be run circumstance-less, they will lose again. Circumstances are a fact of life that all people and organizations deal with or sink.

So listen, GOP: You need to develop a pragmatic streak -- an ability to solve problems through an inspired intellect geared toward the conditions around you. The economic crisis "framed" the election in the Democrats' favor, as Mr. Rove puts it, because the Democrats have the credibility to deal with problems like these. GOP, please understand you need to develop such credibility. And whining about "circumstances" is not the way to go about developing the trust of the American public.

We now know America has lost 1.179 million jobs so far this year . . .

. . . and the unemployment rate has risen from 6.1 percent in September to 6.5 percent in October. From the BLS.gov news release:

Nonfarm payroll employment fell by 240,000 in October, and the unemployment rate rose from 6.1 to 6.5 percent, the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor reported today. October's drop in payroll employment followed declines of 127,000 in August and 284,000 in September, as revised. Employment has fallen by 1.2 million in the first 10 months of 2008; over half of the decrease has occurred in the past 3 months. In October, job losses continued in manufacturing, construc- tion, and several service-providing industries. Health care and mining continued to add jobs.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Robert Gibbs takes on Sean Hannity

A real quick word on Gov. Sarah Palin's future

I wish people would stop calling Gov. Palin 'unqualified' for the presidency. The Constitution lays out the qualifications for the office, and she meets them all.

The word people are looking for is 'unprepared.' Gov. Palin was woefully unprepared to be president. She simply knew nothing about national politics, international relations, party dynamics, and media norms.

Looking forward, Gov. Palin's unpreparedness presents her with a problem and an opportunity.

First, the opportunity. To be a viable candidate, she needs to spend the next four years learning a thing or two. She should begin by poking fun at herself for her performance. She should admit her unpreparedness, and then quickly add something to the effect of: "Hey, I was just doing the role that McCain wanted me to do. I was a team player. Going ahead, everything I need to know I can learn. And I will learn it. I am extremely hard-working, and I am always willing to admit my faults and work on them. I will be back, and I will be a better, more prepared candidate in the future."

Now, the problem. Americans' perceptions of Gov. Palin were shaped solid during this campaign. This is a problem because the McCain campaign used her. She was their attack-dog, and now she looks like a fool for doing the dirty-work that Sen. McCain would not do himself. As a result, Americans think of her not only as lacking knowledge. Perhaps more importantly, they think of her as a highly divisive figure. And in the current 'Obama' environment, divisiveness simply won't get the job done.

In the end, Gov. Palin should have refused the VP opportunity. She should have been more aware of just how unprepared she was. But that's water under the bridge. Now she has to be vigilant. She has to learn something. She has to articulate to Americans that she was just playing the part that Sen. McCain asked of her, and that truly, she is a bi-partisan get-things-done kind of politician. And most of all, she has to gain back a semblance of dignity.

She has to do all these things, and soon. It won't be easy, but it's not impossible.

I'm kind of rooting for her. I see her as a figure who, if she gains knowledge and regains her bi-partisan credibility, could bring the Republicans back from the dead.

But she's got to quit being the know-nothing attack-dog of the Hannity-Limbaugh-Bush wing of the GOP. Run to the center, Governor!

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

The Republican comeback starts now

From Katherine Lopez at the National Review online blog, 'The Corner':

Tomorrow, Brent Bozell, chairman of Media Research Center and President of Conservative Victory Committee is hosting a confab of some right-wing leaders at his rural Va. home.

Greg Mueller of CRC Public Relations says of the meeting: “There will be roughly twenty leaders at the meeting all of whom have been successful fundraisers and grassroots organizers, combined with a few conservative political and media strategists.”

The meeting will address three principle issues, according to one of the attendees. What relationship does the conservative movement have with a GOP that seems to reject conservative ideology — in the last two election cycles the GOP has punted on fiscal issues and avoided cultural issues, the source says. And, (2), "we need to start raising money to fight far left wing extremism." (3) What issues will conservatives need to be ready to battle on.

"The meeting will also discuss who might be the next generation of conservative leaders to run for president and lead the party."

In attendence will be Leonard Leo of the Federalist Society, Grover Norquist of Americans for Tax Reform, Tony Perkins of the Family Research Council, and pollster Kellyanne Conway, among others.

Consider me unimpressed. To get where they want to go, the Republicans need sociologists -- men and women who for their living study human behavior in relation to the qualities of the social environment. Republicans cannot count on themselves alone to understand voters, because they have proven too partisan and too ideologically rigid to see human behavior for what it is rather than what they wish it to be. Republicans need to re-calibrate their principles toward the desires of people. The Conservative movement's problem is, they understand only themselves. They lack any understanding of what it would take to make their party and their principles nationally acceptable again. If they talk only amongst their own kind, they will get nowhere.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Prof. Peter Hart: Sen. Obama is the real conservative in the race

Prof. Peter Hart, a long-time conservative, on why he is going to vote for Sen. Obama.

A speechwriter for Reagan and Nixon—who worked at the National Review for four decades—on why he's voting for Obama.

It may be something of a surprise that, as a long time conservative, I now support Barack Obama. In 1968, I was a speechwriter first for Ronald Reagan, when Governor of California, then, as Richard Nixon became the presidential nominee, a speechwriter for Nixon, working at his home office at 450 Park Avenue. I became a senior editor at National Review in 1969, a position I held until recently.

There are common sense conservatives who are prudential, who try to match means with ends, and who calculate the probabilities of gains and risks. But there are philosophical (analytical) conservatives, the most useful being Edmund Burke, whose "Reflections on the Revolution in France" (1790) understood the great dangers in trying to change society through abstract (republican) theory. My first book that dealt with these matters was "English Political writers: From Locke to Burke" (Knopf, 1963).

Republican President George W. Bush has not been a conservative at all, either in domestic policy or in foreign policy. He invaded Iraq on the basis of abstract theory, the very thing Burke warned against. Bush aimed to turn Iraq into a democracy, "a beacon of liberty in the Middle East," as he explained in a radio address in April 2006.

I do not recall any "conservative" publication mentioning those now memorable words "Sunni," "Shia," or "Kurds." Burke would have been appalled at the blindness to history and to social facts that characterized the writing of those so-called conservatives.

Obama did understand. In his now famous 2002 speech, while he was still a state senator in Illinois, he said: “I know that a successful war against Iraq will require a US occupation of undetermined length, of undetermined cost, with undetermined consequences. I know that an invasion of Iraq without a clear rationale and without international support will fan the flames of the Middle East, and encourage the worst, rather than the best, impulses of the Arab world, and strengthen the recruitment arm of al Qaeda. I'm not opposed to all wars. I'm opposed to dumb wars.”

Burke would have agreed entirely, and admired the cogency of so few words. And one thing I know is that both Nixon and Reagan would have agreed. Both were prudential and successful conservatives. But all the organs of the conservative movement followed Bush over the cliff—as did John McCain.

Obama was the true conservative, the Burkean. Like the French radicals of 1790, Bush wanted to democratize Iraq, turn it, as he said in a speech at Whitehall, into a "beacon of liberty in the Middle East." Now, Robespierre and the other radicals were criticized by Burke for wanting to turn France into a republic. Not a bad idea, but they tried to do it all at once, and according to republican theory.

Maxmillien Robespierre himself would have been horrified by the notion of democratizing Mesopotamia. That may—possibly—happen. But it will take a long time, an Enlightenment, and the muting of sectarian hatreds.

Social Security has long been considered one of the most successful New Deal programs, working well now for 70 years. Yet in 2005, the Bush plan to establish private accounts that could be invested in the Stock Market got nowhere. McCain, too, has embraced this idea. In 2008 it looks ridiculous. The Stock Market! Again, this is a radical proposal, not a conservative one.

Ever since Roe vs. Wade, abortion has been a salient controversy in our politics. But the availability of abortion is linked to the long advancement of women's equality. Again, we are dealing with social change, and this requires understanding social change, a Burkean imperative that Obama understands.

On my Dartmouth campus, half the undergraduates are women. They do not want to have their plans derailed by an unwanted pregnancy. In Planned Parenthood vs. Casey, the Court ruled that the availability of abortion "enables women to participate equally in the economic and social life of the country."

Though there is a tragic aspect to abortion, as Obama recognizes, women's equality means that women have control of their reproductive capability. Men don't worry about that. The fact is that 83 percent of elective abortions occur during the first trimester, and decline rapidly after that.

Both Obama and McCain support federal funding of embryonic stem-cell research, Obama more urgently. The conservative movement publications, following Bush, have been fiercely opposed. Such opposition required a belief that a cluster of cells (the embryo) the size of the period at the end of this sentence is as important (more important?) than a seriously ill human being.

I myself cannot fathom such a mentality.

In fact, embryonic stem cell research is being energetically pursued in the following nations: Israel, Singapore, South Korea, Japan, China cooperating with the EU. Privately funded and state funded laboratories are moving ahead vigorously.

Recently, Harvard announced a program that will be part of a multi-billion dollar science center to be established south of the Charles River, and will be able to supply stem cells to other laboratories. I call that Pro-Life.

This analysis could be extended, but it seems clear to me that Obama is the conservative in the 2008 election.

Source. And I recommend the comments that follow the short article.

Monday, November 3, 2008

The most significant piece of knowledge shaping election 2008

Knowledge is not just empowering. Knowledge also shapes us. It shapes our behavior. It makes us who we are. Simply put, what we think we know tells us how to act. The cliche is 'knowledge is power.' The sociological truth underlying the cliche is less sexy: 'knowledge shapes behavior.' So then, the presidential campaign ends tomorrow -- how did knowledge shape who will be our next president?

The 'wrong track-right track' measurement of Americans' attitudes is the piece of data that most significantly shaped this presidential race. In the current year of 2008, according to one of many measures, 78 percent of Americans say we are on the wrong track while only 4 percent say we are on the right track. That is an unmistakable mandate for a new track. As a piece of knowledge, these data pushed the presidential race in a fascinating direction.

First, we should understand: these wrong-track numbers represent more than the thinking of individual Americans. And they represent more than America's collective conscious. More importantly, the wrong-track data represent the perceived knowledge of both the McCain and the Obama campaigns. What I mean is: The wrong-track numbers are not just a fact about us; the numbers represent perceived knowledge by us. These wrong-track numbers created the race that we have all collectively experienced. The fact that the campaigns knew these numbers determined how the campaigns interpreted their enviroment and were the reason behind the campaign's tactics. Both the McCain team and the Obama team knew the country wanted 'change,' and both behaved accordingly. If Sen. Obama had not known the wish for change, he might never have run for president this early in his political career, in the first place, and run a 'change you can believe in' campaign in the second place. And it is easy to think that Sen. McCain too, had he no knowledge of that data, would have run a considerably different campaign.

First, Sen. Obama. The wrong-track knowledge not only gave power to the Democratic challenger to think he had a chance. It determined Sen. Obama's whole campaign. Sen. Obama and his team seized on the 'change' mantra from the beginning, and never relented it. 'Change' was their entire strategy wrapped up into one word. It articulated just about everything a large voting block of Americans needed to hear.

Second, the knowledge shaped the Republican campaign, too. In my estimation, the huge wrong-track numbers led the McCain team to consider themselves underdogs in the race. They saw that Americans wanted 'change' and felt this created an environment not conducive to their victory. So they ran a wild campaign -- jumping from tactic to tactic, choosing a running mate that helped them in the short run but killed them in the long run, and at the end desperately pumping up a hollow 'Joe-the-Plumber' argument as the winning message.

The problem is, I think the McCain campaign made a strategic mistake. In the face of a liberal, anti-war, black candidate, Sen. McCain should have (a) emphasized his anti-Bush record and (b) run as an experienced, reliable, stable guy in a tough, complex world. He should have been 'experienced change,' change on the bad things, stability with the good things.

But instead of using the wrong-track numbers to their advantage, the McCain campaign tried to obscure them with wild behaviors. This was a huge mistake because, while Obama proponents conveniently forget this, Sen. McCain circa 2001 was the biggest thorn in the side of the Bush agenda. He could have used this fact to his advantage. He could have been the change agent. Someday someone will have to tell me, why didn't Sen. McCain remind us of his anti-Bush history everyday for the final five months of the campaign?

So in sum, the wrong-track knowledge not only represented America's collective conscious, it shaped both campaigns in ways that appear determinative. The following was clear months ago: The candidate who best managed this knowledge was going to win. Sen. McCain should have seen this writing on the wall. Sen. Obama did, and tomorrow, will receive his deserved victory.

The lesson to be learned is that in a world of media and marketing, political and economic winners do not unilaterally impose their message on the public. Instead, winners find their message within the consciousness of the men and women they hope to win over. Once leaders find the message, their job is to manage it their own favor.

The message this year was -- change. Had he accurately read his environment, Sen. McCain would have remained a liberal Republican, rather than tracking toward the Bush-wing of the Republican Party. My belief is, had he remained a Bush critic while articulating a stable persona, he would have won. In which case America would have a different President than it otherwise will have. Politicians: hone your analytical skills. Your future is that contingent upon how the you interpret present moment.

Here are the NY Times' wrong-track data, year-by-year:

I’d like you to compare the way things are going in the United States to the way they were going five years ago. Generally, would you say things are going better today, worse today or about the same today as they were going five years ago?

1986: 44-31 (Better to worse)

1987: 38-31

1988: 30-34

1991: 25-31(March 3-6)

1991: 19-44 (October 15-18)

2003: 14-63

2004: 21-57

2005: 20-56

2006: 18-60

2008: 4-78

Thursday, October 30, 2008

McCain's grave mistake

Why did Sen. McCain run a wild, underdog campaign?

I keep hearing from so-called experts that Sen. McCain, because of his connection to President Bush and his failed policies, was behind the eight-ball before the race even began. That because of Bush, Sen. McCain was the underdog. The truth, as I see it, is that Sen. McCain created his own underdog status by running a Bush-like campaign.

In truth, Sen. McCain was a sharp critic of President Bush -- perhaps the sharpest critic in the entire Congress -- until 2005-2007. This 'we-were-bound-to-lose-anyway-because-of-Bush' reading by Republicans ignores Sen. McCain's past willingness to distance himself from President Bush on many important issues. Why did he turn toward President Bush precisely when the American people turned -- for good -- against him?

For example, I keep hearing Sen. McCain is one and the same with president Bush on the economy. This just isn't true. Or at least wasn't true, until Sen. McCain made it true. Take Bush's tax cuts early in his tenure. The tax-cuts, by all accounts, were supply-side incentives for the investment class. Here's what McCain said about them at the time:

"I cannot in good conscience support a tax cut in which so many of the benefits go to the most fortunate among us at the expense of middle-class Americans who need tax relief."

He doesn't talk that way anymore. Why? If Sen. McCain had kept up this kind of rhetoric, the race would have been entirely different. Now, of all things, he is calling Sen. Obama a socialist because Sen. Obama advocates rolling back these same Bush-tax-cuts that Sen. McCain once opposed. Yeah, I know -- Sen. McCain couldn't have been much such a critic of Bush during the Republican primary. But the day he won the primary, why he didn't move immediately toward this anti-Bush-tax-cut position and criticize the Bush record on, say, jobs is beyond me. My guess is either Sen. McCain mis-read the environment around him, or he was intimidated by the far-right elements of the GOP. Whichever, Sen. McCain has himself to blame for why he will lose this race.

So while I keep hearing that this race is Sen. Obama's to lose, the truth is the opposite. This race was Sen. McCain's to win, and he flat didn't.

The lesson to be learned is: The GOP needs to give itself a bit of a makeover, so it doesn't in the future intimidate its best candidates into beating themselves.

Prof. Francis Fukuyama is voting for Barack Obama

From The American Conservative:

I’m voting for Barack Obama this November for a very simple reason. It is hard to imagine a more disastrous presidency than that of George W. Bush. It was bad enough that he launched an unnecessary war and undermined the standing of the United States throughout the world in his first term. But in the waning days of his administration, he is presiding over a collapse of the American financial system and broader economy that will have consequences for years to come. As a general rule, democracies don’t work well if voters do not hold political parties accountable for failure. While John McCain is trying desperately to pretend that he never had anything to do with the Republican Party, I think it would a travesty to reward the Republicans for failure on such a grand scale.

McCain’s appeal was always that he could think for himself, but as the campaign has progressed, he has seemed simply erratic and hotheaded. His choice of Sarah Palin as a running mate was highly irresponsible; we have suffered under the current president who entered office without much knowledge of the world and was easily captured by the wrong advisers. McCain’s lurching from Reaganite free- marketer to populist tribune makes one wonder whether he has any underlying principles at all.

America has been living in a dream world for the past few years, losing its basic values of thrift and prudence and living far beyond its means, even as it has lectured the rest of the world to follow its model. At a time when the U.S. government has just nationalized a good part of the banking sector, we need to rethink a lot of the Reaganite verities of the past generation regarding taxes and regulation. Important as they were back in the 1980s and ’90s, they just won’t cut it for the period we are now entering. Obama is much better positioned to reinvent the American model and will certainly present a very different and more positive face of America to the rest of the world.

Prof. Fukuyama is one of this country's greatest social scientists and an esteemed conservative. This statement is thus remarkable in its outspokeness. If Sen. Obama continues to receive a mandate from men and women like Prof. Fukuyama, he will receive a giant push toward implementing his largley bi-partisan agenda. This also serves to de-legitimize the Sean Hannity wing of the GOP, hopefully -- hopefully -- pushing them to the fringe so that the party of Reagan can return to being the party of capitalism, not the party of propaganda.

The source.